indexer verifier should report singleton evars
OpenPublic

Description

The indexer verifier should create an error when an evar is used only once (a singleton variable).
This is almost always a typo.
One exception: when a variable is followed by "?".
(You might want to have a flag to control whether this is an error (non-zero return code) or a warning (zero return code).

pludemann created this task.Via WebWed, Mar 15, 5:18 PM
pludemann added a subscriber: pludemann.
Herald added a subscriber: Core Team. · View Herald TranscriptVia HeraldWed, Mar 15, 5:18 PM
zarko claimed this task.Via WebWed, Mar 15, 5:19 PM
zarko triaged this task as "Normal" priority.
zarko added a project: Verifier.
fromberger added a subscriber: fromberger.Via WebWed, Mar 15, 6:59 PM

Maybe we could extend the Var? syntax to include Var! meaning "I intend this to be a singleton and it's OK", and otherwise it's an error? That seems like it would avoid the common case where it's accidental, but gives the test author an easy escape.

zarko added a comment.Via WebThu, Mar 16, 10:30 AM

We already have _ for "don't care". Is there a reason someone might want to come up with their own nonce?

fromberger added a comment.Via WebThu, Mar 16, 10:51 AM

No, probably not. (None that I can think of, anyway)

pludemann added a comment.Via WebThu, Mar 16, 11:03 AM

There's a general convention in Prolog that names starting with "_" (including "_" by itself) are treated as "it's OK to be a singleton". I don't think that this is used often, but I do recall using it, mainly as a documentation thing. (especially as the verifier doesn't have any comment syntax of its own, this could be useful)

Add Comment